Carly Roberts Coaching

About Contact
Log In
Menu
What is a nuanced Mormon? Work With Me Resources for Nuanced Members The Meadow
← Back to all posts

Fantastical Faith

Jul 28, 2026
Connect

"Some day you will be old enough to start reading fairy tales again." 
-C.S. Lewis, to Lucy Barfield

“It is a very silly thing to shut oneself into a wardrobe.”
-The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe

My testimony grew on a cherry tree. The dappled light of the orchard behind my home was alive with buzzes and breezes, and it was here that I read The Chronicles of Narnia that summer, sitting on the thick, waist-high bough of my favorite tree. I couldn't tell you exactly how old I was, nor even if it was my first reading of the series in whole. But it is my earliest memory of feeling changed by something I read. Is "changed" even the right word? Perhaps more than changed I was illuminated...made aware of what already existed inside my soul because someone had turned on the light. I felt wonder that transceded time and space, and it told me to look for the world's magic, even in silly places like a wardrobe.

Perhaps this is why I was such a willing Mormon. Mormonism began with the fantastic: a divine vision, spiritual gifts, and an outpouring from the heavens. Believing in Mormonism felt like drinking from living water. It took something mundane and made it magical. 

The primary trademark of fantasy is that the boundaries aren't what we think they are; the whole point is to bend the rules. And isn't that what Jesus taught? That the rules aren't what we think they are? The wind and the waves can submit. Death is not the end. An eye for an eye is not the ultimate way. Have we stopped looking for the fantastic? I fear somewhere along the line we told ourselves that we had arrived at the truth, and so the goal became endurance at the expense of exploration. We walked into Narnia, then proceeded to watch from the wardrobe.

I invite you today to venture in a little deeper and embrace the unknown. The thrill of disovery doesn't live soley between the pages of a book, nor did it die on the cross. We are all living the heroic journey and a call has been extended to each of us. It comes in many tongues and phrases, but among my favorites is Article of Faith #13:

We believe all things, we hope all things, we have endured many things, and hope to be able to endure all things. If there is anything virtuous, lovely, or of good report or praiseworthy, we seek after these things.

May we all be seekers of the fantastic, the divine, the beautiful, and the good. God's power is greater than we can imagine, but that shouldn't stop us from trying. Journey with me as we go further up and further in.


Announcements and News

  • Expect to see some new resources for nuanced members available on my website. I will be publishing a series of guides to help initiate difficult conversations, beginning with my Baptism Questions for Parents and Children. Be on the lookout for new guides in the coming weeks, and let me know what topics you want to hear about!

 


 


The four pillars of Spiritual Sovereignty

mental awareness â€˘ EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE • value affirmation • spiritual nourishment

 

Receiving Criticism

You admit to being imperfect, but that doesn't make it easy when criticisms arise. Any given instance of correction is an opportunity for defense, a chance to point out why your way is the right way. It is also an opportunity to listen. If you can admit that sometimes you get it wrong, can you also admit that there is a proper way for someone to correct you? Do you allow space for this reality to exist? When you are offered insight to your behavior, do you ever allow people the benefit of believing their perspective, or do you immediately question their validity? What are you worried will happen if you truly consider their perspective?

Is the friction between you and church wearing you down spiritually? It doesn't have to.  Register to be a beta user in "Spiritual Sovereignty", my course for nuanced Latter-day Saints who want to make peace with church without sacrificing their personal values. You get all of my materials—videos, guides, and weekly one-on-one calls— for a fraction of the cost. In exchange, your feedback will help improve the course for future clients. 

 


 

 

 

Responses

Join the conversation
t("newsletters.loading")
Loading...
In favor of pub life
There is a deeply hobbit-ish part of my soul that feels lost and confused, and not because I've had one too many pints. I noticed recently, not for the first time mind you, that I've embraced the popular habit of dissociating behind a screen. And when I manage to break out of my stupor and see the real world around me, I'm a little upset that we've collectively outsourced our social lives to th...
Wait, you're here too?
Have you ever been in a crowd but still felt overwhelmingly alone? I'm more familiar with that feeling than I care to be, and can all too easily conjur up the pit in my stomach that comes with the memories. Sometimes though, I'll be thrown a life preserver. A familiar face will unexpectedly surface from the sea, and the isolation changes to connection.  My husband, Adam, and I noticed this when...
Telling your orthodox family that you aren't
Whether it was a slow creep or sudden flash, at some point you realized that you’re not as orthodox as  a) you used to be b) other people think you are c) other people think you should bed) all of the above But how on earth do you say that to your mother? When church is the family identity, how do you out yourself without ruining your relationships? My thought: maybe you want to ruin them. Hear...

The Meadow

A monthly newsletter for nuanced Latter-day Saints where we share inspiration and tips, and rejuvenate your spirit.
Footer Logo
About Contact
Powered by Kajabi

Join Our Free Trial

Get started today before this once in a lifetime opportunity expires.