Carly Roberts Coaching

About Contact
Log In
Menu
What is a nuanced Mormon? Work With Me Resources for Nuanced Members The Meadow
← Back to all posts

The parable of the hikers

Sep 30, 2026
Connect

Nuanced Mormonism is like unto four hikers, who set about a steep path early in the morning. By midday the air was hot, and there was little shade along the route. Although they soon realized that their water supply was insufficient, they determined to continue along the trail, despite already being very thirsty. They all agreed that a stream was bound to cross the path eventually, at which point they could filter more water for their journey.

Some time later, one member of the group noticed a spring along the mountain. It was set a little way off from the path but still within sight, and she determined to walk over and refill her water supply. She was surprised to find that no one else wanted to go with her. "It is not along the path", they said, "so we're clearly not supposed to use it". Determined to quench her thirst, she offered to bring their empty bottles with her, but they declined, saying they still expected to cross a stream, and they continued walking.

She went to the spring, filled her water, and was hailed with enthusiasm when she returned to the rest of her party. After quenching her own thirst, she offered a drink to her very thirsty companions. They declined, saying there was probably a good reason why the trail didn't cross the stream, and therefore drinking from it should be avoided.

I will, for the most part, leave this parable to you. I will merely offer my observation that many members who "stray" (and yes, please examine what that word means to you) from the church are often welcomed back wholeheartedly and praised for having seen the light. It is often a story of redemption for sin, and rejoicing in a now "mutual" understanding that it was wrong to leave in the first place. I would simply like to posit that we change that story. May we begin to acknowledge that straying from the path often brings knowledge, resources, and perspective that were not obtainable in other ways, and our church is stronger for people having ventured outside its borders. They bring something back with them that we should rejoice in, too.



 

The four pillars of Spiritual Sovereignty

mental awareness • emotional intelligence • value affirmation• SPIRITUAL NOURISHMENT

 

When scripture is difficult

It is not always easy to feel inspired in the scriptures, nor should you feel like you need to. Disagreement and frustration are a valid way to begin or end your study, and a necessary one for scripture to come alive. Return to the scriptures when you can, but remember to do it for your own curiosity, not out of obligation. Bring your imagination to the scriptures, and as always, lay your assumptions on the table and be willing to challenge them. 

 


 

Four Tips for Better Parenting

 


Is the friction between you and church wearing you down spiritually? It doesn't have to.  Register to be a beta user in "Spiritual Sovereignty", my course for nuanced Latter-day Saints who want to make peace with church without sacrificing their personal values. You get all of my materials—videos, guides, and weekly one-on-one calls— for a fraction of the cost. In exchange, your feedback will help improve the course for future clients. 

 


 

 

 

Responses

Join the conversation
t("newsletters.loading")
Loading...
In favor of pub life
There is a deeply hobbit-ish part of my soul that feels lost and confused, and not because I've had one too many pints. I noticed recently, not for the first time mind you, that I've embraced the popular habit of dissociating behind a screen. And when I manage to break out of my stupor and see the real world around me, I'm a little upset that we've collectively outsourced our social lives to th...
Fantastical Faith
"Some day you will be old enough to start reading fairy tales again." -C.S. Lewis, to Lucy Barfield “It is a very silly thing to shut oneself into a wardrobe.” -The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe My testimony grew on a cherry tree. The dappled light of the orchard behind my home was alive with buzzes and breezes, and it was here that I read The Chronicles of Narnia that summer, sitting on th...
Wait, you're here too?
Have you ever been in a crowd but still felt overwhelmingly alone? I'm more familiar with that feeling than I care to be, and can all too easily conjur up the pit in my stomach that comes with the memories. Sometimes though, I'll be thrown a life preserver. A familiar face will unexpectedly surface from the sea, and the isolation changes to connection.  My husband, Adam, and I noticed this when...

The Meadow

A monthly newsletter for nuanced Latter-day Saints where we share inspiration and tips, and rejuvenate your spirit.
Footer Logo
About Contact
Powered by Kajabi

Join Our Free Trial

Get started today before this once in a lifetime opportunity expires.